How listening to the neighbors transformed justice in North Lawndale

– by Jonathan “Pastah J” Brooks

One of my favorite quotes from Dr. Wayne “Coach” Gordon is: “Anything worth doing is worth doing poorly.”

If it’s really worth doing, you don’t have time to cross every T and dot every I. You don’t have time for a perfect concept or a perfect plan or organizational charts. When something is important, when the need is real, you just jump in and say “Let’s start doing something.”

Lawndale Christian Legal Center (LCLC) started out that way. The idea of legal care for the neighborhood popped up on a chalkboard back in 1978. Back then, these Farragut High School students and their wrestling and football coach, Coach Gordon, got together and began to dream about what it would look like to start a church that’s actually for kids like them. Those kids wanted to feel like they didn’t have to change and become something else to be part of a church. They wanted a place that was relevant to them, relevant to the community.

As they pondered what it meant to be relevant, they thought: “Well, let’s just ask our neighbors.”

They sat down and asked their own neighbors what they needed. A lot of needs were written up on the chalkboard in that meeting, everything from violence reduction to healthcare to housing to legal care. And way back then, those kids put their hands to the plow to say “These are all the wonderful things that we can begin to do with our neighbors.” They just got started, and they founded the Lawndale Christian Community Church (LCCC).

But it took awhile before we were able to start LCLC because we were waiting on God to send that person with the expertise and credentials that could help us just begin.

As Coach tells it: “What we were waiting for was the person of Cliff Nellis, who not only was a lawyer, but had just graduated from Seminary. He was the perfect person to get LCLC started. It was on a napkin at Lou Malnati’s Pizza that Cliff and I wrote out the next steps to making the Legal Center a reality.”

overhead image of the lawndale neighborhood

That early foundation that had been building since 1978 was here in Lawndale and ready, and their ethos of keeping community at the center became the blueprint for Cliff as he, Coach, and the congregation began to build LCLC in 2010. 

Right from the beginning, they recruited the first Board a hundred percent from the church and the neighborhood, starting with the people who are most impacted by the justice system in Chicago. They were part of the conversation from the beginning.

What you see in LCLC for the last 15 years is a community-directed approach to working with justice-impacted individuals. Our church provided financial support, space, and volunteer hours, with folks participating on the Board, working the phones at the reception desk, and even doing janitorial work. Because it’s community-led, LCLC has grown and morphed and shifted as the community needs have changed. It started simply: we want to provide high-quality legal care for young people who haven’t been receiving it.

image of an arrow drawn on pavement

As things started to grow, we recognized that we were going to need to do more. You can get a young person cleared from their case, but that doesn’t help them if they’ve been struggling in education. It doesn’t help them if they don’t have a home to go to. It doesn’t help them if they’re struggling financially. And most likely, because of all the other factors that are going on in their life, we’ll probably find ourselves defending them again.

It was pretty clear we needed a more holistic approach. We’ve got to care about the whole person – their housing needs, their health care, their mental care, education, all of it.

So members of our church took on the task of learning how to do that. We trained in peace circles and victim/offender face-to-face conversations. One of my favorite stories is one of the first times we used that training on a real case.

A pizza delivery guy from a store on 26th Street was robbed while delivering pizzas. One of the young men who robbed him was a 22-year-old from our church who’d been an exemplary kid for most of his life but started making poor decisions when he lost his college football scholarship and returned home not knowing what to do next.

Rather than resolving the case solely through the Cook County system, we decided to hold a peace circle and restore justice at our own legal center.

The victim had been attacked in his community. He was just trying to do his job. In the peace circle, the young adult who robbed him got to witness the impact and trauma his poor decision-making caused this family. And the young man apologized, admitting he didn’t think through the trauma his actions would cause.

The community of peers in that peace circle decided the young man should work alongside the older man, helping him deliver the pizzas and clean up the store on the weekends. He did, and their relationship grew.

The older man did more than forgive him. He started to treat him like an adopted son.

This is justice.

“You rob somebody for a certain amount of money, you go to jail, end of story” isn’t justice. That doesn’t help anyone. When people get to see each other as human beings, when relationships grow to the point of supporting each other, you no longer have a victim and offender relationship. You have a community. You have something that looks like the kingdom of God.

Stories like that one are what we hope will become the norm because of the Dr. Dennis Deer Community Justice Center.

Dr. Dennis Deer was part of our congregation, a coworker, a fraternity brother, and an amazing friend. I feel like this building being named after him is so apt because his heart was to see people in our community being restored.

photo of doctor dennis deer

Dr. Deer found a way to use his political affiliations and faith-based affiliations to bring forth vision and financing for this center. He was adamant that if we were going to be an alternative to incarceration, then we needed to look different than the Department of Corrections. We needed to stay focused on community and show people that whatever they’ve been through, they can be restored right in their own neighborhood.

The fraternity Dr. Deer and I are part of, Omega Psi Phi Fraternity, Inc., has a motto: “Friendship is essential to the soul.” We believe that relationships will be the key to changing the lives of the young men who will live in the Deer Center. We’ll have the services – the financial, mental health, physical health, and wellness, but in addition to all of that, the men of our fraternity from the Rho Mu Mu Chapter will spend our time there mentoring and building relationships. We’ll be making sure residents know they have people who really believe in them. My biggest hope for the Deer Center is that it will be a place that will feel essential to the soul of every single one of the young men who stay there.

image with text that says prayer is an act of resistance

I look at prayer as an act of resistance against all the things that try to tell us not to have hope, to tell us that nothing will ever change. And I say often to my congregation that we want to be a people of prayer, but we don’t only want to pray with our lips. We want to pray with our feet.

A few weeks ago, some of us from Lawndale Christian Community Church walked through the Deer Center tangibly writing prayers on the beams, prayers that will cover the folks who will live and work there, that will literally, physically surround them. It was one of the best moments I’ve had as a pastor.

The Deer Center, to me, is what love looks like. When you love someone, you go over and above to fight for justice for them. You never stop defending them. You keep praying. You keep showing up. You build them a place to feel safe.

You don’t ever wonder why you’re doing it. It’s worth doing, so you just get started.

That’s just what love does.

In early 2025, you’re invited to join LCLC in celebrating the opening of The Dr. Dennis Deer Community Justice Center (you can RSVP here) and taking the next big step toward a new era of restorative community justice. For more information or to learn how you can get involved as a donor or volunteer, visit www.lclc.net